律师法
sampleattorneyopinionletter
date
(nameofclient)
president
***co.,ltd
city,state,zipcode
re:opinionletterregarding(nameofemployee,e.g.,fictitious****)
dear(name):
afterourinitialmeeting,ireviewedthepapersyousentmeregardingthe****matter.asiunderstandthesituation,ms.**signedawrittenemploymentagreementwithyourcompany.theagreementstatedthatintheeventofterminationorresignationfromherjobasyoursalesassociate,ms.**wouldnotcalluponorsellgoodstoanyofyourcustomersforaperiodofoneyear.
youhaveaskedmetoadviseyouaboutyourrights,thechanceofsuccess,theamountofdamagesthatmayberecoverable,thecostsinvolved,andmyabilitytorepresentyouinthismatter.
rightsof***againstms.**
whenms.**signedawrittencontractwithyourcompany,sheagreednottocalluponanyofyourcustomersforaperiodofoneyear.thisiscalledarestrictivecovenant.toenforceyourcovenantagainstms.**,youmustbringanactionagainstherandproveyourcase.youhaveachoiceofforumsinwhichtobringtheaction:federaldistrictcourtorastatecourt.sinceitiseasiertoobtainaninjunction(anactiontoimmediatelystopherfromsellingtoyourcustomers)inastatecourtratherthanafederalcourt,iwouldsuggestthestatecourt.
imustadviseyouthatinjunctionsarelargelydiscretionarywiththecourt,andthereareseveralfactorsherethatmightleaditnottograntoneonyourbehalf.sinceyouwaitedeightmonthsbeforethreateningtosuems.**,myguessisthatyouhaveaboutatwentypercent(20%)chanceofobtaininganinjunction.
rightstoandamountofdamages
yourchancesofobtainingmoneydamagesagainstms.**aremuchgreaterthanyourchancesforaninjunction.fromourdiscussionandthefactsandevidencesuggestedinyourpapers,itappearsthattheamountofrecoverabledamageswouldbemeasuredbytheprofitsyouhavelostsincethetimems.**begansellingcompetitiveproductstoyourcustomers.
itshouldbeunderstoodthatifwewinourcase,however,ms.**maynotvoluntarilypaythejudgment.thus,itmaybenecessarytoenforcethejudgmentbyhavingasherifformarshallseizeandsellassetsnotexemptfromexecution.however,ifms.**doesnotownassets,suchasrealestate,moneyinbankaccounts,stocks,etc.,butownsonlypersonalitemsexemptfromexecutionunderthelawsofourstate,thenanyjudgmentyouobtainmaynotbeworthmuch.
negativestolawsuit
besidesthefactthatyoumaylosealawsuitagainstms.**orthatanyjudgmentobtainedmaybeuncollectible,thereareothernegativefactorsyoushouldconsiderbeforebringingalawsuit.theseincludecourtcostsandattorneyfees.courtcostsarerecoverable,butothercosts,suchastravel,thetimelostwhenyouarecalledtotestify(orrequiredtohelpusdevelopthecase),andattorneyfees,arenotrecoverable.
myservices
iamfamiliarwiththenatureofyourmanufacturingbusinessandamqualifiedtorepresentyouinthismatterifyouchoosetoproceed.myfeewouldbebasedonmynormalhourlychargeof$250formyselfand$150forassociates.trialtimeisbilledat$1,000perday.theinitialservicesofpreparingacomplaintandservingsamewouldcostapproximately$300.preparingarequestforaninjunctionandattendingahearingontheinjunctionwouldcostapproximately$2,500.
itisquitepossiblethatms.**wouldnotretainherowncounselandnotanswerthecomplaint.thismeansthatadefaultjudgmentcouldbetakenwithoutthenecessityofatrial.hereattorneyfeeswouldprobablyamounttonomorethan$1,000.
irequirea$1,000retainertoopenafileandcommenceanaction.
ifyouwishtoproceedwiththismatter,iwillneedtoknowthefullnamesandaddressesofyourcustomerstowhomms.**ispresentlysellingandtheestimatedsalesvolumewhichyouhavelost.
ifyouhaveanyquestions,pleasecallme.
verytrulyyours,
nameofattorney